My PhD has changed direction. Do I need to rewrite my research questions?

Here's a situation that might sound familiar.

You're several years into your PhD, you've collected your data, you've done your analysis, and you've learned an enormous amount about your research topic.

There's just one teeny, tiny little problem.

Your research questions don't seem to fit what you've actually done anymore. 😬

Perhaps your research has taken a completely different direction from the one you originally imagined. Which is completely normal BTW. Now you're looking at those research questions you wrote several years ago, slightly cringing at them, and thinking, “What the fiddlesticks am I supposed to do with THESE?!”

Well, first of all, don't panic.

Your research questions aren't necessarily supposed to remain exactly as they were when you started your PhD. Your understanding of your topic has developed enormously since then, so it's perfectly reasonable that your questions might need revisiting.

But how do you go about doing that?

1. Start with what you've actually done

Put your original research questions to one side for a moment.

Instead, ask yourself:

  • What have I actually investigated?

  • What have I learned through my research?

  • What am I now in a position to say something meaningful about?

The idea here is to get a clearer picture of the research you've actually undertaken, rather than trying to force everything back into the shape you originally imagined.

2. Work backwards from your findings

Now, have a look at the main arguments emerging from your analysis.

Ask yourself:

What questions would someone need to ask for these findings to constitute a meaningful response?

You're looking for the bigger questions connecting your findings, rather than creating a separate research question for every theme or category.

Think about what your findings collectively help us understand.

3. Check the connections

Once you've drafted some possible revised research questions, it's time to check how everything fits together.

Ask yourself:

  • Do these questions fit with my overall research aims?

  • Are they consistent with my methodology and research approach?

  • Can I actually answer them using the data I've collected and analysed?

  • Do they connect with the contribution I'm making to knowledge?

You want your research questions to reflect the study you've undertaken, while ensuring that the different elements of your PhD still make sense together.

One important thing before you go changing everything!

Revising your research questions isn't the same as inventing questions that conveniently fit your findings.

That's an important distinction.

In qualitative research, research questions can legitimately evolve as your understanding develops. But you still need to be able to explain and justify how and why those changes occurred.

If you're considering substantial revisions in the final stages of your PhD, please discuss them with your supervisors before making any big changes. Okay?

Your PhD isn't necessarily supposed to end where it started

One of the things I often remind PhD researchers is that the PhD you finish isn't necessarily the PhD you thought you were going to do when you started.

That's not automatically a problem.

Research is a process of discovery. Sometimes what we discover changes what we realise we need to ask.

It’s like I always say - the true direction of your PhD only really starts to appear once you start walking.

It’s a journey you plot when you’re walking it.

The important thing is being able to explain how your research developed, why your questions changed, and how everything fits together in the thesis you've actually written.

So, if your original research questions are looking a bit bewildered by the PhD you've ended up doing, perhaps it's time to introduce them to the research you've actually undertaken. 😂

What next?

If you’re trying to stitch your PhD together at the end, my Complete PhD System will help you identify the thread across all of the sections and get everything all lovely and coherent.

Previous
Previous

Why is writing up qualitative data analysis so difficult?

Next
Next

Why we don't offer discounts at Degree Doctor (and why that's deliberate)