Why is writing up qualitative data analysis so difficult?

Qualitative data analysis is a wolf in sheep’s clothing.

Sure, it looks fairly innocent and if you’re someone who’s passionate about getting right into the detail of people’s experiences and producing research that genuinely makes a difference, the whole thing can be kind of EXCITING at the outset, right?! You’re looking forward to geeking out on it all.

And then… the complexity kicks in. Urgh.

All that lovely data that you’ve spent hours collecting, coding, reading, sorting, thinking about… it totally defies any kind of attempt to organise it. It’s like trying to get a wriggling toddler into a sleepsuit. WAAAAAAHHHH!

I recently asked PhD researchers on my Instagram stories what their biggest data analysis headache was.

Writing up came top of the poll.

I asked a few people what they were finding particularly difficult and their answers pointed to one key problem:

Turning what you've done into a clear, convincing explanation.

Let's look at a few places where that gets tricky.

1. You've described your findings. But have you explained them?

One researcher told me they had their themes, but their writing kept slipping into description. They were reporting what participants said rather than explaining what it meant.

This is incredibly common. We all disappear down the little descriptive side road, no matter how hard we try not to!

Imagine a study where several participants describe feeling that they don't belong at university.

You could write:

"Participants described feeling out of place, particularly when talking to students from different backgrounds."

That's useful description, all well and good.

But now ask yourself:

What does this tell me about belonging?

Maybe that belonging is about more than just the volume of people in your social circle or contacts in your phone - maybe it’s about whether you FEEL you belong in that environment.

Now you're developing an interpretation. Get you. 😉

You've moved from what people said towards what you think is going on.

Crucially, you need to show readers how the data supports that interpretation.

2. You know theory matters. But where does it actually go?

Another researcher told me their supervisors kept asking them to ground their quotes in theory.

Which sounds terribly academic, doesn't it? Exploding head emoji, right?!

But what does it actually mean? To put this into normal-person speak:

How does this idea help me understand what I'm seeing in my data?

Suppose you're using a theory about social identity.

Rather than introducing a quotation and then mentioning the theory, you might use that theory to explore why a participant felt excluded or how they understood their position in a group.

Theory should help you do some thinking rather than just being dusted on at the end by the barista like chocolate sprinkles on your cappuccino.

It’s also worth me saying that you don't necessarily need to extend or challenge a theory in every paragraph. Sometimes using it to explain your findings is exactly the job - there will be some theory out there that does a fine job of explaining what you found, and that is all!

3. You've got far too much material

One researcher described working through a huge volume of material. Lots and lots of interviews, multiple chapters with tens of thousands of words each - yes, EACH!

That's a LOT of material and it’s easy to drown in that and live in that awful sense of overwhelm.

Your job now is to decide what matters most for answering your research question.

Try asking:

  • What is the main point I'm making in this section?

  • Which evidence helps me make that point?

  • What is interesting but doesn't really belong here?

You might have spent weeks analysing something that ultimately gets two sentences in your thesis.

Annoying? Absolutely. SO annoying.

But that's part of making analytical decisions., folks! Sorry! 😉

4. You can't find the story

This is where several of the responses came together.

You've got quotations, codes, themes, theory and pages of writing. But what's the argument? Maybe your supervisor has even said something like, “I can’t see your argument” Great, thanks.

Try completing these three sentences:

My analysis suggests that...

I think this because...

This matters because...

Scruffy sentences will do. The point is to work out what you're trying to say before worrying about how elegantly you're saying it.

Once you can explain your main point, it becomes easier to decide which evidence belongs where.

5. You're waiting to feel certain

One postdoc who responded described feeling isolated in their qualitative work and losing confidence after receiving feedback that their analysis hadn't gone far enough.

I think that's an important reminder that these difficulties don't magically disappear when you finish your PhD.

Qualitative analysis involves making decisions that could often have been made differently.

There may be several reasonable ways to interpret something so rather than looking for THE answer, you need to develop one that makes sense, is grounded in your material, fits your approach and can be explained clearly.

You can be uncertain and still be doing thoughtful analysis. That’s kind of how we roll in qualitative research, another lesson of the hidden curriculum that it would have been nice to know about, right?!

So what should you do next?

If you're struggling to write up your qualitative analysis, don't automatically assume you need to recode everything or start your findings chapter again.

Instead, ask yourself:

Am I struggling to describe what I found, explain what it means, connect it to theory, decide what matters, or organise it into a clear argument?

Those are different problems requiring different solutions.

Once you know which problem you're actually trying to solve, the next step becomes much easier to see.

Found this helpful? Have a nosey at my other blogposts here.

Next
Next

My PhD has changed direction. Do I need to rewrite my research questions?