Why reading more won’t fix your PhD literature review
As a PhD researcher, you do a lot of reading. It comes with the territory, obviously.
There are things about academic literature that you didn’t quite understand until you started studying for a PhD. For example, the sense of achievement when you finally tracked down that article you’d been after for ages - whether that was through a convoluted inter-library loan process or a detective-style hunt across all corners of the internet. Ah, the satisfaction.
Then there are the no-so-gratifying moments, like that graveyard of PDFs on your desktop that judge you every time you open your computer.
There is never a shortage of things to read as a PhD researcher, you can always be reading more.
Why reading more isn’t always the best thing to do
Reading is important, don’t get me wrong, but it can have a problematic side to it if you start reading for the wrong reasons.
Like when you read to feel productive, when you feel the need to do something that feels like progress.
Perhaps it’s the first thing you reach for when you have that stuck feeling, when you’re trying to work something out and you’re just getting super frustrated about it. Reading can fill that gap.
Not sure what to write next in the middle section of your literature review? Okay then, I’ll read.
Not sure if this area of the literature is relevant? Perhaps reading will clear things up.
Erm, no. It likely won’t.
Focus on what you’ve already read
Most literature review problems are not reading problems. They’re not going to be solved by reading more.
The issue is usually understanding the value of what you've already read.
There is likely something in the reading you’ve already done that you haven’t quite made sense of yet.
Adding more papers on top of that is not going to make it any clearer, it’s just going to add to the mental load.
It's a bit like your finances. Sometimes it's easier to dream up ways of making more money than it is to look at how you're already spending it.
Reading more can be the PhD equivalent of sorting through your wardrobe to find things to sell on eBay or Vinted, rather than opening your banking app and noticing you've spent an alarming amount of money on coffees and pain au chocolats this month.
One activity feels productive and proactive. The other requires you to stop, look closely, and make sense of what's already there.
Reading another paper can feel productive in the same way. It gives you something to do. But it doesn't necessarily solve the problem.
Questions to ask instead
Sometimes the real work isn't finding more literature. It's sitting with the literature you already have and asking:
Where in my literature review do I currently feel most confused?
What do I think I need to understand better?
What patterns, tensions, or ideas keep appearing in the literature I've already read?
Don’t worry if you feel confused whilst you’re doing this.
Confusion is often evidence that you're in the middle of making sense of something complex, and the most productive thing you can do right now isn't to read more, but to ask better questions of the literature that's already sitting in front of you.
If you’re currently wresting with your literature review, my guide will help you work out what matters and get words on the page. Learn more here - Literature Review PhD Survival Guide.
“I’ve read so much, but I still don’t know what I’m trying to say”
You've probably read hundreds of papers, highlighted articles, filled notebooks with ideas, and downloaded more PDFs than you can count.
Yet your literature review still feels messy.
Everything seems relevant. The literature feels disconnected. You're not sure what to include, what to leave out, or whether you're building an argument or simply accumulating information.
The most important thing to understand here is this:
There’s a tendency to think that if you just read more, everything will become clearer - and unfortunately, some supervisors seem to think this works too. It doesn’t. Most of the literature review problems I saw students experiencing in my 20 years in academia were caused not by a lack of reading, but by not having a structure for making sense of what they’d already read.
This guide helps you build that structure.
Designed specifically for qualitative PhD researchers working with thematic or narrative literature reviews, this guide helps you move from collecting information to interpreting and synthesising it, so you can build a clear, critical, defensible literature review that you can confidently explain and stand behind.
Inside, you'll find 12 carefully sequenced sections and practical worksheets to help you:
• Make sense of the literature you've already gathered
• Identify patterns and develop meaningful themes
• Turn disconnected notes into a coherent structure
• Move from summary to critical analysis and argument
• Decide what belongs in your review and what doesn't
• Stop endlessly rewriting and start making confident decisions
• Build a literature review that genuinely supports your research questions
If you've ever thought:
"I've read loads, but I still don't know what I'm trying to say."
"Everything feels relevant. I can't see what actually matters."
"I know there's an argument in here somewhere, but I can't quite find it."
"My supervisor says I need to be more critical, but I don't know what that actually means."
"I keep rewriting my literature review, but it's still not quite working."
This guide was created for you.
By the end of this guide, you'll have a clearer sense of how your literature fits together, what matters for your study, and how to structure your chapter.
Most importantly, you'll feel more directed, more confident in your thinking, and far better able to explain and stand behind your literature review.
This is a digital download. You’ll get immediate access to the full guide and worksheets as soon as you purchase, so you can start making progress straight away.
Swipe through the images to see exactly what’s inside.
For a more streamlined and coherent approach, you can access all four PhD Survival Guides in the full series here.
Got questions? Contact me using this form, I’ll be happy to help.
By purchasing this product, you agree to our Terms & Conditions.